9 Easy Thanksgiving Desserts Everyone Will Save Room For
Every year it’s the same theatre. The table groans, the turkey disappears, and one by one your guests push back their chairs announcing they couldn’t possibly eat another bite. Then someone carries in the pie, and suddenly everyone discovers a separate dessert stomach. These thanksgiving desserts lean into that moment — the classics everyone expects, a few clever make-ahead bakes, and one no-bake cheesecake for when the oven is spoken for. Most of them taste better made a day early, which means dessert is sorted before the big day even starts.
Pick one showpiece pie, one easy traybake or crumble, and something no-bake, and your dessert table is covered for every taste at the table.
1. Classic Pumpkin Pie
Bake a day ahead · Better after a night in the fridge
The one dessert Thanksgiving is not allowed to skip. A smooth, warmly spiced custard — tinned pumpkin purée, cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg and a pinch of clove — baked in a crisp pastry case until the edges are set and the centre still wobbles gently. Blind-bake the crust briefly so the base stays crisp, let the pie cool slowly to avoid cracks, and serve with softly whipped cream.
Shortcut: a shop-bought pastry case is the week’s best time-saver — under spiced filling and cream, nobody can tell.
2. Pecan Pie Bars
Make ahead · Keeps 4–5 days in a tin
All the gooey glory of pecan pie, in tidy squares. Press a simple shortbread base into a lined tin and bake until pale gold, then pour over a filling of butter, brown sugar, eggs, vanilla and plenty of chopped pecans. Bake until just set, cool completely, and slice. Bars portion without fuss, travel happily, and keep guests nibbling long after dinner.
Shortcut: leave a parchment overhang — lift the whole slab out and slice on a board for clean edges.
3. Easy Apple Crumble
Assemble in the morning · Bakes while you eat
Tart cooking apples tossed with sugar, cinnamon and a squeeze of lemon, under a rubble of buttery crumbs. Assemble the whole dish in the morning and keep it in the fridge; when the turkey comes out, the crumble goes in, and dessert bakes while you eat. Serve warm with custard, cream or vanilla ice cream — the contrast of soft fruit and crisp top is the whole point.
Shortcut: make a double batch of crumble topping and freeze it — handfuls ready whenever fruit needs using up.
4. No-Bake Pumpkin Cheesecake
No oven needed · Set overnight in the fridge
For when the oven belongs to the turkey. A base of crushed spiced biscuits, then a cloud of cream cheese, pumpkin purée, icing sugar and pumpkin spice, lightened with folded whipped cream. Chill at least six hours, overnight if you can — it slices cleanly and tastes refreshingly light after a heavy meal. Finish with whipped cream and a dusting of cinnamon.
Shortcut: set it in small glasses instead — no slicing, built-in portions, and it looks like a planned dessert course.
5. Sweet Potato Pie
Bake a day ahead · Flavour deepens overnight
Pumpkin pie’s deeper, earthier cousin. Roast or boil sweet potatoes and mash them silky-smooth with butter, brown sugar, eggs, milk, cinnamon, nutmeg and vanilla, then bake in a pastry case until set with a gentle wobble. Roasting the potatoes first concentrates their flavour beautifully. Serve at room temperature or chilled, with whipped cream and an extra dusting of nutmeg.
Shortcut: tinned sweet potato purée is a fine stand-in — drain it well and add an extra pinch of spice.
6. Pumpkin Roll with Cream Cheese Filling
Make 1–2 days ahead · Chills and slices beautifully
The one that looks like a patisserie made it. A thin spiced pumpkin sponge is rolled up warm in a sugared tea towel so it learns its shape, then unrolled, spread with tangy cream cheese filling, and rolled again. Chill, dust with icing sugar, and slice to reveal the spiral. It keeps happily for two days as the flavours settle in.
Shortcut: roll the sponge the minute it leaves the oven, towel and all — waiting even five minutes invites cracks.
7. Cranberry Orange Trifle
Assemble morning-of · Needs 4+ hours to settle
Layers doing the decorating for you: sponge cubes, tart cranberry compote and orange-scented custard under a blanket of whipped cream, all shown off in a glass bowl. The cranberry’s sharpness is exactly what a rich meal needs at the end, and the orange keeps it bright. Build it in the morning so the sponge softens without collapsing, then finish with fresh cranberries and zest.
Shortcut: shop-bought sponge fingers, cranberry sauce loosened with orange juice, and ready-made custard — assembled in 20 minutes flat.
8. Mini Pumpkin Pies (Muffin Tin)
Bake a day ahead · Built-in portions
Classic pumpkin filling in individual pastry cases, baked in a muffin tin until just set. No slicing, no serving stress, and everyone — especially children — loves getting their own pie. They bake in about 25 minutes, chill neatly, and any leftovers travel home with guests instead of haunting your fridge. Crown each one with a small swirl of whipped cream.
Shortcut: cut the pastry with a round cutter slightly wider than the cups — no measuring, and scraps re-roll once.
9. Chocolate Pecan Pie
Bake a day ahead · Serve at room temperature
For the relative who “doesn’t like pie.” Stir a generous handful of dark chocolate chips through a classic pecan filling and they melt into fudgy pockets between the nuts. Bake until the edges are set and the centre softly wobbles, then cool completely before slicing — the filling needs the rest. Serve small slices with unsweetened whipped cream or vanilla ice cream.
Shortcut: run the knife under the hot tap before each cut — clean slices through the sticky filling every time.
Save Room. Always.
However full everyone claims to be, dessert is where the day ends on a high note — so plan it with the same care as the turkey. Choose your favourites, make what you can ahead, and let the rest be simple. Need the savoury half sorted too? Our easy Thanksgiving side dishes cover the middle of the meal, or browse all our easy recipe ideas for more inspiration.
📌 Save this post on Pinterest so these thanksgiving desserts are always one tap away.
